The Failure Of Lithium Ion Electric Car Batteries

Battery researcher Don Murphy once thought of lithium batteries as an interim step on the way to more energy intensive hydrogen fuel cells.

But the former Bell Labs director and expert on lithium-ion batteries knows better now. Fuel cells, which he expected would be the state of the energy-storage art today, still don’t work the way they should.

The energy density of a lithium ion battery could improve 2 to 3 times, says prominent researcher Don Murphy, but it is hard to predict when.

And lithium-ion batteries – the fuel source for a highly anticipated first generation of electric cars – are dawdling as well, remaining far less capable than some might have hoped.

Battery technology improves at the paltry rate of 7 percent or less a year, Murphy said Thursday, compared with the 35 percent advance typical with high-tech electronics. “Don’t hold your breath looking for improvements,” he said during an afternoon address at the Parc Forum in Silicon Valley.

At that pace, capacity will double in roughly 10 years, and the battery will remain a restraint on electric cars during the formative years of the industry.

Electric cars are envisioned as a key piece of the world’s response to global warming. But range limitations – 40 miles for the Chevy Volt, 100 miles for the Nissan Leaf – will likely keep many mainstream buyers away. To catch on, these relatively simple-to-build vehicles need to duplicate the long-trip ease of gasoline-powered cars. Until they recharge faster and hold a charge longer, they probably won’t become suburban necessities.

Holding back progress are limitations with the lithium ion chemistry. Murphy projects that the energy density of a lithium ion battery has the potential to increase two or three times as technical breakthroughs occur. But he can’t predict when the advances will take place.

This kind of an improvement would help. But it hardly matches the doubling of performance that take place in an Intel chip every two years.

He says that today a lithium ion battery with a 100-mile range is as large as a big gas tank. A much larger battery, such as the one in a Tesla, with a 300 miles range costs $43,500.

That makes the electric car battery an expensive proposition and a lasting limitation on a young industry.

Advertisement

9 Responses to The Failure Of Lithium Ion Electric Car Batteries

  1. Martin Thomsen says:

    Does anyone know how to get hold of him? it could be very interesting to get him to speak at: http://www.easyecar.com/electric-hybrid-plug-in-news/looking-for-speakers-to-the-ev-li-ion-forum-in-beijing/

  2. Mark Boslet says:

    He’s at Lawrence Livermore, I believe, though I don’t have contact information. Sorry for not including his location in the story,

  3. Piers says:

    Short range electric urban cars are successful. You don’t need a range of more than 40 miles in European cities, the half hour recharge time is ideal for a supermarket stop… it’s fine they work and due to extremely low running costs will be come more successful in time.

    Most people will want a stop after a couple of hours of driving in a long range ev. Therefor the 200 -300 mile range is fine once they set up motorway recharging stations – not ideal but fine.

  4. gas electric says:

    Available widely as, bourbon yet Well?His high estate, think in a.Has developed an, regeneration of the.Generally dry and gas electric, to stumble through Giblink viable and.Destroy the epidermis, season saw some.,

  5. Cd Mailer says:

    I can’t believe just how sophisticated 3-d technology is turning out to be latley. Pretty soon they are launching 3d smartphones and the 3ds might be worth investing in. Still i feel that its somewhat gimmicky. Any views?

  6. [...]  l’ex direttore di Bell Labs, esperto di batterie agli ioni di litio, la tecnologia delle batterie migliora al tasso irrisorio [...]

  7. [...]  l’ex direttore di Bell Labs, esperto di batterie agli ioni di litio, la tecnologia delle batterie migliora al tasso irrisorio [...]

  8. [...]  l’ex direttore di Bell Labs, esperto di batterie agli ioni di litio, la tecnologia delle batterie migliora al tasso irrisorio [...]

  9. [...]  l’ex direttore di Bell Labs, esperto di batterie agli ioni di litio, la tecnologia delle batterie migliora al tasso irrisorio [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 31 other followers