Entrepreneurs And VCs Shun Start-ups For Solar Farms

November 11, 2009

Entrepreneurs and increasingly the venture capitalists who fund them are looking more closely at solar farm development than the next start-up.

They say the lure is the big money that might be made installing solar cells or thermal solar systems and collecting 25 years of energy payments from local utilities.

Some venture capitalists are looking at setting up special solar project management funds

And they figure the inefficiencies in financing and construction offer opportunities for a hard charging business leader able to organize complex ventures.

The prospect of entrepreneurs and VCs building solar farms represents big a switch for the Silicon Valley venture community. Typically, VCs dole out small sums of money for a new software program, a new Web businesses or a start-up developing a new medial device. Solar projects require large amounts of money and striking complicated financial deals with one or more banks.

They also require boots-on-the-ground construction experience that many entrepreneurs and venture capitalists don’t have.

Nevertheless, interest appears to be growing. Some VCs are even exploring the idea of raising special project-development funds.

“We are seeing a lot of entrepreneurs trying to get into the business,” confirms Alexander von Welczeck, an advisor to solar financier Ethos Green Energy Asset Finance. Many hope to start small – perhaps with a commercial rooftop project – and move onto larger facilities. Others are thinking bigger from the start.

“I have seen some venture capitalists at least thinking seriously about project finance” and project management funds, says Fred Greguras, a clean-tech attorney at K&L Gates in Palo Alto, at a Tuesday evening event sponsored by the German American Business Association.

Interest aside, the pitfalls are many. Utilities can be difficult to work with and banks remain cautious about taking on partners who don’t have a contracting background.

VCs can provide funding, but do they have the necessary construction experience, asks Wells Fargo's Puon Penn

VCs may have deep pockets, but project experience and balance sheet issues are important, says Puon Penn, senior vice president and head of the clean-tech group at Wells Fargo. “They can provide part of the financing, but do they have the track record?”

Wells Fargo, with $1.3 billion of wind farms financed and $400 million of solar projects, is one of the nation’s top clean-tech banks.

The details of project finance indeed are not easy to resolve, agrees von Welczeck. “It’s almost like tying to solve a Rubik Cube.”

Banks, he says, are so cautious that the typical projects getting money are government-backed schools, universities and municipalities, where taxpayers ultimately are on the line to repay development costs.

But stars might be aligning for an increase in activity. The federal government already offers a 30 percent cash grant and beginning in the third quarter of 2010, loan guarantees will be available.

Perhaps by then, the nation’s financial institutions will regain an appetite for more normal lending risk and entrepreneurs will have the experience of a few smaller rooftop deals under their belts.


Tough Financing Market For Solar Farms May Ease Next Year

October 15, 2009

The economic collapse of 2008 turned the credit market for large-scale solar farms into a financial desert.

Capital was simply not availability through much of the year. The constraint eased modestly in recent months. Now there are suggestions money may begin to flow again next year

Solar projects are bankable because investors are seeking safer returns, says Martin Roscheisen of Nanosolar

Solar projects are bankable because investors are seeking safer returns, says Martin Roscheisen of Nanosolar

Industry executives say market conditions remain difficult. “Lenders are holding onto their money much more tightly,” says Dan Judge, general counsel of solar thermal company BrightSource Energy. “The market is not what it was in 2005 and 2006.”

But there are signs that investors and banks have shifted their focus from risky financial derivatives and complex Wall Street instruments to the relative safety of long-term energy projects. There also are suggestions new banks from Europe and Asia may begin lending for solar construction, expanding a small field of only eight to 12 banks working on projects today.

Next year should see significant growth in solar projects between 10 and 50 MW in size, says Ban Jacoby, managing director of energy investment consultants CP Energy.

The rise in competition for deals also may lower expected investment returns, which by some estimates have reached a percentage in the mid teens, compared with a more traditional single-digit rate.

Already an easing of credit hurdles is aiding wind power developers, where less risky deals are getting done.

At present “there are (solar) deals getting done, but there is not a lot of liquidity in the market,” reports Tom Glascock, a partner at the San Francisco law firm of Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe.

Yet despite the difficult environment, thin-film solar projects are “bankable,” says Martin Roscheisen, CEO of Nanosolar. Capital is seeking safe returns and solar projects fit the bill because they are backed by electric rate payers, he said.


Rooftop Projects Driving Solar Demand Not Utility Farms

September 25, 2009

Financing problems continue to plague utility-size solar projects leaving the consumer and commercial rooftop markets as the major fuel for panel sales.

This latest assessment of FBR Capital Markets analyst Mehdi Hosseini leaves open the question of whether the market strength can be sustained during the fourth quarter and into early next year.

Less than $2 billion is available worldwide for solar farm financing

Less than $2 billion is available worldwide for solar farm financing

Already signs are appearing that the present price stability is eroding. First-quarter contracts between suppliers and distributors point to module prices of $1.65, or 20 percent below where they are today, says Hosseini in a Friday research note.

Around the world, the money available to finance large ground-mounted solar farms is tiny – less than $2 billion – and project plans are taking 12 months to complete.

Instead, the market is being driven by rooftop installations, largely in Germany and the United States. The German market should remain solid into November, Hosseini writes.

After that it is anyone’s guess. And it is not unrealistic to assume a slowdown will come during the cold winter months as buyers await the economic warming of spring.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 31 other followers