EV Standards Advance Goal Of Consumer Simplicity

June 30, 2010

On the surface, the move to electrify the world’s transportation system seems a straightforward replacement.

Plug your vehicle into an electrical outlet instead of fill it with gas, and substitute one form of energy for another. Below the surface, the switch is anything but simple.

That’s why the evolution of smart-grid standards is so critical and why it needs to be followed closely. This is especially true of the deliberations at SAE International, where in May the first in a series of five communications standards for electric cars was published in draft form.

SAE International is developing five related communications standards for electric cars

The standard is among the first to help dictate how power will flow from the electric grid to EVs. Specifically, the proposed J2836/1 standard will govern network communications as cars plug into charging stations at home, work and during travel. The goal of the standard is to enable utilities to handle new demands for power, especially during peak-load periods, and to encourage consumers to charge off-peak when power is cheap and plentiful.

Rich Scholer, HEV E/E systems engineer at Ford Motor Company, said the draft standards incorporate basic techniques for load balancing and demand response, such as temporarily turning off an air conditioner to balance the draw of a quick, middle-of-the-day, peak-load charge at home.

It also will support the delivery of consumer pricing tables, so cost savings can motivate charging decisions.

Scholer, chair of the SAE International’s hybrid task force, says the committee’s goal is to keep behind-the-scenes complexities hidden from consumers. The interface at a home charging station might offer the choice of a fast or slow charge and leave the network to handle the details. “We’re trying to make things so they are relatively intuitive and simple,” says Scholer.

More than 200 companies are working with the hybrid task force, including carmakers General Motors, BMW and Honda, and the utilities PG&E, Southern California Edison and Progress Energy. The entire series of standards could take as long as three years to evolve. The first, the J2836/1, is targeted at utilities while future standards will address off-board charging, diagnostics, two-way energy flows and other topics.

Until then, vendors will need to develop workarounds for their products and incorporate agreed-upon technologies when they become available.

One challenge facing the task force is in coordinating with standards efforts taking place in Europe and Japan. Scholer says the task force is meeting with the International Organization for Standardization and the International Electrotechnical Commission for that purpose.

“We’re all trying to harmonize,” he said, adding that this goal of integration is “doable.”

A second thrust is to keep the finished product from becoming too complex, especially with the number of companies involved. It is an objective Scholer says he intends to achieve.


White House Feels Heat On HAN Standards

May 28, 2010

The White House is feeling industry pressure to complete an initial set of HAN standards as fears of a smart-grid information bottleneck grow.

Pressure falls on NIST to finalize home area network standards for smart grid

The heat is coming from appliances manufacturers who hope to enlist administration support in the National Institute of Standards and Technology review now underway to assure interoperability among competing standards and protocols.

NIST published a “roadmap” document in January with a preferred list of smart grid and home area network standards, but a schedule for final selection doesn’t appear to be in place. The aim of the review is prevent market confusion and divergence, and to promote open communications. NIST hopes to establish 77 smart-gird standards over the next few years with 14 this year.

“This has to be done as quickly as possible, “ concedes John McDonald, a general manager at GE and chair of the governing board of NIST’s Smart Grid Interoperability Panel. “There has been a lot of pressure at the White House.”

Among the leading candidates in the initial HAN standards race are the wireless technologies Zigbee and Wi-Fi and the powerline technology HomePlug. Determining a final list will provide big benefits if utilities are to deliver on the promise of demand response and greater system efficiency. Utilities need an effective distribution system with reliable two-way communications extended into the home if they hope to lower residential loads during high demand periods –perhaps by delaying defrost cycles in refrigerators or reducing power to stove tops.

California is waiting for national action so it doesn't place standed assets in the field, says CPUC Utiliites Energineer Wendy Al;-Mukdad.

From the industry perspective, standards will lower products costs and simplify development. At GE, a new hybrid water heater comes with a Zigbee connector on its side instead of integrated inside. That way it can be replaced if standards favor a different technology. However, integration would make the product less expensive to manufacture.

Product design is of particular important to companies such as Whirlpool, which promises to have 1 million smart dryers in the market by the end of 2011.

NIST’s next step is to broaden its examination of technologies beyond the Unites States to determine how technology development in places such as Japan and China might influence deployment here.

Despite the work ahead, McDonald says he is serious about getting the standards work completed sooner rather than later. It that means changing the leadership, then a change needs to be considered, he says.

He adds: “If we don’t have the house situation worked out, it’s going to be a bottleneck.”

The fallout from the lack of standards is already being felt in places such as California, where the California Public Utilities Commission put off smart grid decisions for fear of placing non-standard equipment in the field.

The commission wants to make sure utility investments don’t become “stranded assets,” said Utilities Engineer Wendy Al-Mukdad at this week at the ConnectivityWeek conference in Santa Clara. As a result, “We’re waiting for a lot of the national action on standards and protocols” to conclude.


Router Company Highlights Failure Of Smart Grid Standards, Forms Independent Working Group

April 6, 2010

Smart-grid router company SmartSynch highlighted the failure of smart-grid standards Tuesday by forming an independent industry group to push for needed standards in communications gear.

Stephen Johnston said that despite three years of efforts, standards still are missing for smart meters and network equipment.

GridRouter maker Smartsynch hopes to push for IP-based communications standards on the smart grid. It has attracted a small group of supporters including AT&T and Motorola.

Now with utilities pouring billions of dollars of federal funds into early stage smart-grid efforts, projects risk of falling short from equipment that doesn’t interoperates or which can’t be easily installed.

Smart-grid standards initiatives date back more than three years. Yet smart meters from a company such as GE don’t work alongside one from Elster or Landis-Gyr, or connect smoothly to a GridRouter from SmartSynch.

“Without standards, we could be setting up the smart grid to be not as good as it could be,” Johnston said. “It’s a huge problem.” Prices also could be higher since competition among vendors is reduced.

On Tuesday, SmartSynch hopes to make a dent in the problem by forming an “ecosystem” group around its GridRouter. The group will push for interoperable, IP-based standards and has attracted several big name supporters: AT&T, Motorola, Rogers Communications, Itron, Cooper Power Systems and Battelle Energy. “We anticipate more,” Johnston said.

A day earlier, executives from Google, Intel, Honeywell, GE, AT&T and venture firm Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers made news with a letter to President Obama. They called on the Obama Administration to make the distribution of energy-use data to homes and businesses a priority.

But without standards, this could be more difficult than it seems. “If every utility deploys a proprietary system, those utilities can’t benefit from each other,” says Johnston.


HD Television Vendors Line Up Behind Rival Wireless Standards

December 12, 2008

High-definition televisions sporting wireless connections have yet to hit most retail shelves, but vendors are tussling over standards for this latest consumer feature.

An outdoor, wireless, weatherproof TV

An outdoor, wireless, weatherproof TV

Two industry groups are lining up behind rival 5 GHz and 60 GHz technology proposals.

The 5 GHz standard is based on technology from Israeli-based Amimon, and is backed by Hitachi, Motorola, Sharp, Samsung and Sony, says ABI Research. The companies formed the WHDI Special Interest Group.

Mitsubishi, separately, has said it will use Amimon technology.

The 60 GHz approach is designed by Sunnyvale startup SiBEAM and has drawn the support of Intel, LG Electronics, Matsushita Electric, NEC and Toshiba. This WirelessHD group also claims Samsung and Sony, who are hedging their bets.

Broadcom also has joined the consortium, said ABI analyst Steve Wilson.

Amimon has shipped 100,000 of its wireless chipsets and is making “real progress promoting its solution,” says Wilson. SiBEAM, meanwhile, has a new round of fundraising and has won investments from Sony and Panasonic.

In Japan, Sharp and Hitachi are shipping high-end wireless televisions. In the U.S., Sony has its Bravia wireless adaptor available in some retail outlets, said Wilson.

Expect to see new models at January’s Consumer Electronics Show.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 31 other followers