The Failure Of Lithium Ion Electric Car Batteries

February 19, 2010

Battery researcher Don Murphy once thought of lithium batteries as an interim step on the way to more energy intensive hydrogen fuel cells.

But the former Bell Labs director and expert on lithium-ion batteries knows better now. Fuel cells, which he expected would be the state of the energy-storage art today, still don’t work the way they should.

The energy density of a lithium ion battery could improve 2 to 3 times, says prominent researcher Don Murphy, but it is hard to predict when.

And lithium-ion batteries – the fuel source for a highly anticipated first generation of electric cars – are dawdling as well, remaining far less capable than some might have hoped.

Battery technology improves at the paltry rate of 7 percent or less a year, Murphy said Thursday, compared with the 35 percent advance typical with high-tech electronics. “Don’t hold your breath looking for improvements,” he said during an afternoon address at the Parc Forum in Silicon Valley.

At that pace, capacity will double in roughly 10 years, and the battery will remain a restraint on electric cars during the formative years of the industry.

Electric cars are envisioned as a key piece of the world’s response to global warming. But range limitations – 40 miles for the Chevy Volt, 100 miles for the Nissan Leaf – will likely keep many mainstream buyers away. To catch on, these relatively simple-to-build vehicles need to duplicate the long-trip ease of gasoline-powered cars. Until they recharge faster and hold a charge longer, they probably won’t become suburban necessities.

Holding back progress are limitations with the lithium ion chemistry. Murphy projects that the energy density of a lithium ion battery has the potential to increase two or three times as technical breakthroughs occur. But he can’t predict when the advances will take place.

This kind of an improvement would help. But it hardly matches the doubling of performance that take place in an Intel chip every two years.

He says that today a lithium ion battery with a 100-mile range is as large as a big gas tank. A much larger battery, such as the one in a Tesla, with a 300 miles range costs $43,500.

That makes the electric car battery an expensive proposition and a lasting limitation on a young industry.


Microsoft Records The Sound Of A Tesla

November 20, 2009

Road racing games such Microsoft’s Project Gotham Racing and Forza bring realism to the digital driving experience by duplicating the sound of squealing tires and the roar of engines.

But what about an electric car? How does it sound? Isn’t the whir of the motor completely different?

Screeching to a halt from 119 miles an hour was a fun way to use electrons, says Tesla owner Tom Burt

These question brought Microsoft game engineers together with Tesla owner Tom Burt for an on-the-track day of recording Burt’s Roadster screeching to a halt from 119 miles an hour.

In a blog entry, Burt says he heavy braking was a fun way to use electrons.

“The brakes got quite hot after three of the 119 mph runs, which ended with hard/threshold braking to slow the car before running out of pavement. The sound they recorded as we blew by at these speeds was fantastic.”

The day began at 7:30 a.m. when sound engineers from Microsoft Game Studios wired the $98,000 car with three large boom microphones suction-cupped to the sides and rear. Two other mics were attached up front over the sway bars near the front tires, and another was placed in the trunk. A final mic went inside the cabin.

Burt said that in addition to the abrupt braking, he performed hard sweeping turns, which generated “good tire chirps at the edge of adhesion (and) then more aggressive skids.”

Finally, “the team asked for ‘longer’ squeal segments, (and) we did tight circles just fast enough to keep the tires howling continuously for 30 seconds or so.”

The motor overheated after several full speed accelerations and the car under-steered, given its stock suspension settings and tire sizes, Burt said. But when it was all over, he was relieved to find he had enough juice in the battery to drive home.


Tesla Motors To Take Over NUMMI?

August 27, 2009
Tesla CEO expressed would love to take over NUMMI

Tesla CEO recently said he would love to take over NUMMI

A few months ago, I remember Tesla Motors CEO Elon Musk warming at the idea of taking over NUMMI, the sole auto assembly plant on the West Coast.

Musk comments did make a lot of people laugh. Back in April, when the prolific entrepreneur spoke at a Churchill Club event, GM and Toyota were still committed to keep the 20-year old joint-venture running and Tesla was still waiting for government loans to help it jumpstart its future sedan “model S” vehicle project.

But after a tumultuous 4-months that  saw GM file for bankruptcy, sever its partnership at NUMMI, Tesla raising nearly a $1 billion from both the government and private investors and finally, Toyota announcing today it will not keep operating alone the Fremont, Calif., car plant, Musk’s “pipe dream” of taking over NUMMI could very well happen!

“Maybe at some point there’ll be an opportunity to acquire NUMMI. That’d be great. I’ll take that in a second. But that isn’t available right now,” added Musk.

A golden opportunity for Tesla indeed, that is required – by receiving the government loans – to find a 20+ year old plant to produce its upcoming all-electric “S” vehicle. And NUMMI just celebrated it’s 20 years anniversary… this year!

“But we can’t afford it right now, unless they give it to us. Which maybe they will,” said Musk 4 months ago!

And “they” (including the state, local and even perhaps the federal governments) might indeed make it so attractive that Tesla could actually find it hard not to move to NUMMI. Wait and see!

Follows the video excerpt where Tesla CEO Elon Musk eluded at the idea of taking over NUMMI:


Solar Startup Plans To Take Internet Business Model To Southern California

April 8, 2009

Solar energy is all well and good. But if you can’t easily get solar cells from the factory to a residential rooftop, what is it worth?

The dilemma is a little like the one facing electric car startups, such as Tesla. If a company doesn’t have a national network of dealers, how big can its car sales become?

Sungevity will announced three down-state installers on April 22

Sungevity will announced three down-state installers on April 22

Sungevity hopes to solve the solar challenge. The company has been installing solar cells on homes in the San Francisco Bay Area using an Internet-based ordering technique that lets homeowners choose from five competing systems. The process eliminates the site visit by relying on satellite maps – and potentially saves buyers money.

Co-founder Danny Kennedy says the startup does two to four homes a week.

Now it plans to take its business model on the road and expand to Southern California. It will be an interesting experiment to watch.

Sungevity plans to announce a partnership with three down-state solar installers on April 22. The expansion will enable it to cover 65 percent of the state.

The company could be serving 5 percent of the entire California market by 2010 or 2011, says Kennedy – a big step.

While sales turn down over the winter, partly due to the economic downturn, business has recently shown some life. “We’ve picked up again,” he said.

It will be interesting to see the company’s reception down south.


Why Tesla Motors Trashed Plug-In Hybrids Idea

April 8, 2009
For Tesla Motors chief, GMs Chevy Volt is a mule!

For Tesla Motors chief, GM's Chevy Volt is actually a mule!

During his talk at the Churchill Club last night, Tesla Motors chief Elon Musk defended his case on why he did not believe plug-in hybrids were a good solution for cars.

But first of, to avoid being accused of bashing the whole plug-in hybrid concept (which he did at the end, by the way!), Musk repeated that he wished GM’s plug-in hybrid – the Chevy Volt – a lot of success; even though he knows it will be a lamentable failure!

Musk then went onto the nitty-gritty (battery pack, engine weight, generator, drivetrains…) of why plug-in hybrid cars were just the wrong solution versus a pure electric car.

A plug-in hybrid car is anemic

I didn’t understand all his reasoning, so I encourage you to watch the video I took of it below.

“But [on a plug-in hybrid] when you consume your 40 miles [of electric power], you then end up with an engine that is super really underpowered. Like a lawnmower engine trying to power a sedan. So it’s going to be running high RPM, working really hard… it’s going to feel really anemic,” explains Musk.

Comparing a plug-in hybrid engine to a lawnmower engine is a bit harsh. But hey, he’s the expert!

Musk ended saying that knowing the fix mass and cost of a car, engineers can either create a better gasoline car or a better electric than if you split the baby i.e. a plug-in hybrid car!


Tesla Motors Chief Downplays Fisker Automotive Plug-In Sedan

April 8, 2009
Fisker Automotives Karma plug-in hybrid sedan is sportier than Tesla Motors

Fisker Automotive's Karma plug-in hybrid sedan is sportier than Tesla Motors'

Speaking at the Churchill Club last night, Tesla Motors chief Elon Musk downplayed rival’s plug-in sedan.

“Fiskers is building a plug-in hybrid [more on that on another post]…  it’s [the Karma] a sportier sedan than ours,” confided Musk.

However, for Musk Tesla’s S all-electric sedan is intended to be very functional with a lot of cargo space, carrying 5 adults in comfort and potentially 2 kids – yes, that’s 7 total! – and still have room for luggage.

And did I forget to mention, it’s all-electric… no gas!

“And we’re roughly at a $50,000 price point and they’re around $80,000 starting price after the tax rebates,” adds Musk.


Musk: After Paypal, SpaceX, Tesla Motors? Nano-fusion, Prefab Highways, Electric Plane

April 7, 2009
Elon Musk next venture could be a nano-fusion reactor, prefab highways and an electric plane!

Elon Musk next ventures could be a nano-fusion reactor, prefab highways and an electric plane!

Despite having his “mind full” with Space X, Tesla Motors and family matters (5 kids!), uber entrepreneur Elon Musk has still a bit of time left to think about his next big ideas which includes nanoscale fusion, prefabricated highways and a supersonic all-electric plane!

“At some point in the future, I will take a look at fusion. That’s a tough problem. But I think it’s something humanity can solve. And maybe there’s something I can be helpful there,” said Musk speaking tonight at a Churchill Club event hosted at Microsoft’s Mountain View. Calif.- campus.

The co-founder of Paypal is also dreaming of double-decker highways made of  “prefabricated sections” with very efficient metallic structures that could withstand the worst of earthquakes. “The trick will be making it light, strong and inexpensive. And I think I know how to do that,” added Musk.

Finally, Musk, which went from surviving on $1 a day to being one of Silicon Valley’s billionaires and perhaps the modern day Jules Verne, have this idea of an electric supersonic jet. “I have to ban that idea from my mind… [because] it’s very exciting.”

Here’s Elon Musk talking about his next dreams:


Tesla Unveils $50,000 ‘Mass-Market’ Electric Sedan; But No Factory Yet

March 26, 2009

At the SpaceX Rocket Factory in Los Angeles today, Tesla will show off a prototype of its Model S.

tesla-sedan-launch The all-electric luxury sedan – comparable to a BMW 3-series or a Mercedes C-class – will cost half the price of Tesla’s sporty Roadster, at around $50,000 (after a federal tax credit) when it goes on sale in 2 years; allowing time for more rigorous testing before it actually hits the road.

The San Mateo, Calif.-company still awaits to receive a $350 million loan from the Department of Energy to build its factory in San Jose to produce Model S cars.


Detroit: Tesla Motors Does *Not* Need Government Funding To Survive, CEO Declares

December 12, 2008
Tesla Motors will reach profitability next year reveals CEO Elon Musk.

Tesla Motors will reach profitability next year reveals CEO Elon Musk.

As much as Detroit needs a $34 billion government bailout to keep the lights on and continue building gas-guzzling pick-ups, minivans and SUVs, Silicon Valley startup Tesla Motors does not require Federal money to survive.

The $40 million the San Carlos, Calif.-company secured last month is twice what it needs to reach profitability next year, said CEO Elon Musk this week.

However, the 300-person company is still going after a $450 million government loan to accelerate the production of its upcoming model “S” 5-passenger all-electric sedan and its power-train factory.

“The sedan program is $350 million. This is tiny compare to what Detroit is asking. It’s like a month interest,” said Musk, “Compare (it) to $34 billion. We’re like less than 1%. It’s like ridiculous. We’re asking for less than 1% what Detroit is asking for…It’s quite reasonable to me.” Musk said he would use another $100 million to build the power-train factory that will supply other car companies.


Tesla Motors CEO: Model “S” All-Electric Luxury Sedan, San Jose Plant To Be Delayed 2 More Years Without U.S. Government Funding

December 9, 2008
Elon Musk is hoping to get U.S. funding to accelerate 4-door electric car programme

Elon Musk is hoping that U.S. Federal funds will accelerate its 4-door sedan electric car project

At a press conference at Tesla’s store in Menlo Park, Calif., Elon Musk confirmed that without the U.S. government subsidies, the Silicon Valley electric car company will have to delay the manufacturing of its future $60,000 all-electric luxury sedan by at least 2-years.

“We don’t need the government fund to pay for the design of the sedan version of our electric car which is mostly done; it will be unveiled in the February time frame. We already have a mule down in our facilities in Los Angeles. But we need the money to accelerate the program to build the factory,” explains Musk.

With public markets still in flux, the U.S. government is the only alternative for Tesla Motors to raise the money necessary to build its $250 million factory in San Jose, Calif.

“It will take 2-years to build the factory after we get the Federal money. But without it, we’ll have to wait at least 2-years before we could raise money from the public markets and then 2 more years to build the plant. And that’s a big deal for a mass-market car,” adds Musk who’s “family car” is a 4-seat Porsche Turbo.

Despite the uncertainty, the serial entrepreneur is confident his model “S” sedan electric car will be built and sold no matter what. However, the Federal money will just make it happened a lot sooner!


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 31 other followers